Please don’t label me!
It’s a worry, really. As we gear up to celebrate Christmas in a society that barely knows the story which lies behind the tinsel and glitter, are we forcing our religion on our children? The British Humanist Association certainly thinks so, and they are launching a new advertising campaign with the slogan “Please don’t label me. Let me grow up and choose for myself”.
The irony is that the smiling, carefree children on the poster, images sourced from a photography website, are the son and daughter of Brad Mason, drummer for the Christian musician Noel Richards. He says that this shows his children are happy, and that their Christianity shone through, which is what made the images special. The humanists respond, however, that labelling children fails to respect their rights and autonomy.
The trouble with the suggestion behind the campaign is that it implies that children are like blank sheets of paper upon which we are imposing our design – sheets of paper which would, but for our interference, remain unsullied until they decide for themselves how to fill them in. Children, as we all know, are more like blotting paper. They absorb what they come into contact with.
No Christian parent could help but share the love of God with their child. Not just because we want them to know – and of course we do! – but because if we are living the Christian life then our actions, our words, our life will reflect our belief. It will be the reality the child grows up with and they will, while they are children, know themselves as Christians in the same way they know they are members of our family. To suggest that they remain in a state of non-belonging until they are old enough to make their own decision is a bit like suggesting we refrain from teaching them our language in case they later want to speak another!
And if we do not tell our children about the world, others will. There are plenty of world views competing for their attention. Their friends, school, television – there are many influences shaping the lives of our children. Even if it were possible for us not to shape their views there are plenty of others who would step in to fill the void.
Of course our children do grow up. And for all of them there does come a stage when they re-evaluate the world for themselves and we know all too well that while some of them continue to follow Jesus some of them make other decisions. What they have learned when they were growing – not just what they were told but what they experienced – will be a part of what influences them, but the decision to respond to God’s call is one that each person makes for themselves. For most of us brought up in a Christian household it is not a sudden blinding conversion; we either remain in the Christian faith we were brought up in, making a conscious though often gradual decision to say yes to Jesus’ call, or wander away, deliberately or accidentally. Many who do so will come back later; some, sadly, will not. 
Belief is something that cannot be imposed on anyone. Jesus watched in sadness as people he had called walked away from him, drawn by other things. But because he loves us he came to tell us about God in words and in loving deeds. We can and must do no less for our children.
These commandments that I give you today are to be upon your hearts. Impress them on your children. Talk about them when you sit at home and when you walk along the road, when you lie down and when you get up. Tie them as symbols on your hands and bind them on your foreheads. Write them on the doorframes of your houses and on your gates. (Deuteronomy 6:6-9)
Jane Cornish
Another view was expressed by Justin Thacker, Head of Theology at the Evangelical Alliance, who said: "It is great to see that the Humanists are now agreeing that children have to make their own decisions about faith. Evangelicals do not believe that God has any grandchildren, only children. You are not a Christian simply because your parents are. Every child or adult has to make up their own minds about the reality of God.”
You are invited share your thoughts on this issue by clicking the Add your comment box at the bottom.
Jane Cornish is a Reader at All Saints church in Ipswich. She is actively involved with local Traidcraft activities, and regularly contributes to Scripture Union Daily Bread Bible notes. You can contact her at jane@cornish.org.uk
The views carried here are those of the author, not of Network Ipswich, and are intended to stimulate constructive debate between website users. We welcome your thoughts and comments, posted below, upon the ideas expressed here.
|